AI Governance Policies 101: Drafting Effective Guidelines for AI Development and Use
Content

Our Newsletter

Get Our Resources Delivered Straight To Your Inbox

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
We respect your privacy. Learn more here.

TL:DR

Artificial intelligence (AI) is already changing how we do business and how we live. Its capabilities are quickly rendering traditional programming governance policies and standards obsolete, yet these programs are used to make decisions that significantly affect people’s lives.

AI governance policies are frameworks that facilitate the ethical and responsible use of AI technologies. These policies aim to eliminate bias and increase AI accountability and transparency in systems. Businesses also implement AI governance policies to comply with existing data privacy and protection regulations as well as new and emerging AI regulations.

Understanding AI Governance Policies

As Christian Lange stated over 100 years ago, “Technology is a useful servant but a dangerous master.” An AI governance policy helps keep AI technology firmly in the servant category. It’s a structured framework intended to promote the responsible development and use of AI technology. These policies address the ethical, legal, and society-wide ramifications of AI so businesses and governments can take advantage of the potential of AI without causing harm.

Definition and Scope

AI governance policies define standards and practices for developing and using AI to make sure they’re implemented in ways that are fair, transparent, and accountable. They’re applicable to every stage of AI development, from planning to deployment. Effective governance policies prevent potential harm such as privacy violations and biases in decision-making and promote beneficial and equitable outcomes.

Key Elements of AI Governance Policies

The field of AI governance is still in its infancy, with the EU leading the way in regulating AI technologies. The EU AI Act was passed in March of 2024 — though it will be gradually phased in over 24 months — and the White House issued a Blueprint for an AI Bill of Rights that will likely shape future US regulations. You can expect more international, federal, and state regulations to follow in the near future.

However, for now, businesses are largely on their own in developing governance policies. Your AI governance framework should be customized to your specific use cases, but all policies should include the following elements.

Ethical Guidelines

An AI governance policy should clearly outline the ethical principles you’ll follow in developing or using an AI system. This includes promoting fairness, equity, and respect for human rights. These policies can do this by requiring measures such as bias mitigation and inclusivity. Your governance policy should also include guidelines for considering the wider ethical implications of AI decisions. AI systems that have more power need more ethical governance.

Compliance Requirements

Although AI-specific regulations are currently limited, AI technology still needs to comply with existing laws and regulations. Governance policies should outline how you’ll adhere to data protection laws, industry standards, and international regulations, so your AI programs won’t infringe on individual rights or privacy.

Risk Management

Your governance framework should include practices for identifying, assessing, and mitigating risks associated with AI technologies. You need to systematically evaluate the potential for unintended consequences, security vulnerabilities, and the impact of AI decisions on individuals and communities. A strong risk management framework will help you anticipate and respond to challenges effectively.

Transparency Measures

AI concepts such as machine learning algorithms and neural networks are complicated and difficult for lay people to understand. Standards that call for transparency in AI systems, including clear documentation of AI models, decision-making processes, and data sources, can help build trust with consumers and society. Transparency measures should also extend to how businesses and governments use AI systems so people aren’t deceived.

Importance of AI Governance Policies

Depending on who you believe, AI will either save the world or destroy humanity. Even if you fall into the dwindling middle ground and don’t buy into either extreme, AI undoubtedly has the power to reshape our society for good or ill. AI governance policies aim to shift the balance towards the good side.

Ethical AI Development and Use

When you’re designing an AI application to offload a tedious and time-consuming task, the benefits seem obvious, and the potential negative repercussions less so. However, because machine learning programs often operate in a “black box” — that is, even their creators aren’t sure how they'll make a decision — they may be discriminating against people based on race, gender, or other protected classes. AI explainability can shed some light on this process, but it's not available in all systems.

Even if an AI technology isn’t discriminatory, its widespread use may lead to unforeseen consequences. Generative AI has already increased the productivity of many software teams, and there’s concern that it may replace wide swaths of knowledge workers, which could decimate the economy if left unchecked.

AI governance policies put guardrails on AI programs to prevent individual and community harm from AI.

Regulatory Compliance

An AI governance policy will help you comply with all applicable laws and regulations in your industry and use cases. Noncompliance carries the risk of significant financial and legal penalties. The AI regulatory landscape is rapidly changing, so an AI governance policy should be flexible enough to adapt to new laws.

Risk Management

Governance policies provide frameworks for assessing potential risks, such as biases, security vulnerabilities, and unintended consequences. By implementing robust risk management strategies, you can proactively address these challenges and implement more reliable and secure AI systems.

Building Trust

Clear guidelines on fairness, privacy, and data protection reassure users and customers that their rights are respected. AI transparency measures, such as explainable AI and thorough documentation, allow stakeholders to understand how AI programs make decisions. When you demonstrate a commitment to responsible use, you create a trustworthy environment with your customer base and the broader community.

Steps to Draft Effective AI Governance Policies

To create AI governance policies that reflect your ethical, legal, and operational concerns, you need to consider how you incorporate AI into your current business practices and how that role is likely to expand in the future. The following steps will help you lay the groundwork for effective AI governance.

Establish Clear Objectives

The first step in drafting your AI governance policies is to determine exactly what you want to achieve. Identify the specific AI applications it will cover along with data sources and other related systems. This starting point will give you a clear direction and guide the rest of your plan.

Engage Stakeholders

AI systems can affect people at all levels of your organisation. Include voices from all departments and disciplines, including developers, data scientists, executives, legal representatives, and users. Input from all impacted groups will help you create more holistic and comprehensive policies.  

Conduct a Risk Assessment

The ultimate goal of your governance policies is to protect people from risks associated with AI. To do this, you need to identify potential legal, financial, social, and operational risks. After you perform AI risk assessments, you can develop strategies to mitigate these risks.

Define Roles and Responsibilities

AI governance is an ongoing job that’s best managed by a team with wide-ranging representation and expertise, including data and security. Your framework should clearly define who will be on the team and what their responsibilities are.

Develop Ethical Guidelines

Your AI ethical guidelines should align with your corporate values. It should answer questions about how you’ll use AI in your organisation and how your core values will guide your AI adoption. You can draw on your existing ethical frameworks to identify best practices and gaps you should cover. Establish accountability measures such as oversight committees and regular audits.

Establish Compliance Mechanisms

Compliance mechanisms guarantee your AI systems adhere to relevant laws, regulations, and ethical guidelines and protect users’ rights. Start by identifying all regulations that apply to your industry and use case. Then set up comprehensive compliance policies that outline how you’ll meet all the specific regulatory requirements, including training programs and reporting systems.

Implement Monitoring and Auditing Processes

Your AI governance policies only have value if you follow them closely. Continuous monitoring helps you discover issues early so you can correct them. Determine what aspects of your AI systems need to be monitored, such as data inputs and decision-making processes. Set up real-time monitoring systems that can track the behavior of your AI systems and alert you to noncompliance.

In addition to regular monitoring, your governance policies should include measures for periodic audits. Develop detailed protocols that outline auditing procedures, including the frequency, scope, and methodologies of audits.

Create a Feedback Loop

A feedback loop will incorporate insights from stakeholders and your existing systems to improve your governance policies over time. Consider different feedback sources, such as users, developers, monitoring systems, and audit reports. Set up multiple channels for collecting feedback so they’re easily accessible. Develop processes for analyzing it as well — you may need to use data analysis tools to identify issues and areas for improvement. Incorporate these insights into your AI governance policies going forward.

Best Practices for Implementing AI Governance Policies

Once you’ve established AI governance policies, you need to follow a systematic approach to implementing them throughout your organisation.

Regular Training and Awareness Programs

You’ll have better implementation results for your AI governance policies if everyone understands their value and significance. Provide ongoing educational programs that explain ethical guidelines, compliance requirements, and best practices for responsible AI use.

Transparency and Communication

As you develop and implement your AI governance framework, maintain open lines of communication about policy details, updates, and compliance requirements. You can do this through clear documentation, holding regular informational meetings, and providing updates through multiple accessible channels.

Continuous Improvement

Your AI governance framework isn’t a static document. You should update it regularly based on new risks, technologies, regulations, and experience. Take the feedback you receive and advice from experts and use it to improve your policies and keep up with AI advancements.

Challenges in Drafting and Implementing AI Governance Policies

Rarely does any substantial change come off without a hitch, in any organisation. If you’re like most businesses, you can expect to face some challenges when drafting and implementing AI governance. Some of the most common challenges include:

  • Rapid AI advancements make it difficult to craft relevant, updated policies.
  • Stakeholder buy-in can be lacklustre due to competing priorities.
  • Overly strict governance policies can stifle innovation.

You can overcome these and other challenges by consulting legal and ethical experts to make sure your guidelines are comprehensive and forward-looking. Engage stakeholders at all phases of development and implementation to address their needs and concerns. They’ll be more likely to adopt policies they’ve had a voice in creating. There’s no slowing progress, but if you establish a process for regularly reviewing and updating your procedures, you can stay on top of industry changes and stay relevant.

Final Thoughts

Effective AI governance policies safeguard against risks such as biases, security vulnerabilities, and regulatory breaches and promote fairness and accountability. Investing in comprehensive, adaptable governance frameworks also builds trust in your brand and supports sustainable innovation and long-term growth.

Zendata AI Governance simplifies compliance, risk identification, and stakeholder engagement. Our detection, prevention, and correction controls provide insights and mitigate risks related to AI adoption in your organisation. Reach out today to find out how we can help you.

F‍AQ

How can businesses effectively manage the ethical risks associated with generative AI technologies in their AI governance policies?

Managing ethical risks in generative AI involves incorporating specific guidelines within AI governance policies that address the unique challenges posed by these technologies. This includes setting strict parameters for data usage to prevent misuse and ensuring that outputs are regularly audited for quality and ethical standards. Businesses should also engage in continuous risk assessments to adapt to the evolving nature of generative AI applications, ensuring they remain aligned with ethical principles and compliance requirements.

What specific transparency measures should organisations implement to clarify the decision-making processes of black-box AI models?

To enhance transparency in black-box AI models, organisations should implement detailed documentation practices that describe the data inputs, model architecture and algorithms used. Additionally, they should provide accessible explanations that can be understood by non-experts, such as simplified visual representations of how decisions are derived. Establishing regular transparency audits can also help ensure that these measures are consistently applied and effective.

In what ways can AI governance frameworks be tailored to mitigate biases specifically in AI recruitment tools?

AI governance frameworks tailored to mitigate biases in AI recruitment tools should include mandatory bias detection and mitigation procedures throughout the AI model development and deployment phases. This could involve training on diverse datasets, regular bias audits and the implementation of fairness algorithms. Additionally, these frameworks should enforce transparency in how recruitment decisions are influenced by AI, with clear documentation and the option for candidates to request explanations for automated decisions.

How can organisations ensure that their AI governance policies remain effective amidst rapid advancements in AI technology and changing regulations?

To ensure AI governance policies remain effective, organisations should adopt a dynamic approach that includes regular policy reviews and updates in response to technological advancements and regulatory changes. This involves setting up a dedicated oversight committee that monitors AI developments and compliance landscapes. Creating a culture of continuous learning and adaptation among employees and stakeholders through training and awareness programs can help maintain alignment with best practices in AI governance.

What role do data privacy laws play in shaping AI governance strategies, particularly in international operations?

Data privacy laws significantly shape AI governance strategies by setting legal standards for data handling and protection that organisations must comply with, especially in international operations. These laws influence how AI systems are designed, particularly in terms of data collection, storage, and processing practices. Organisations should develop compliance mechanisms within their AI governance frameworks that are strong enough to address the diverse requirements of different jurisdictions, ensuring global compliance and protecting user data across all operational areas.

Our Newsletter

Get Our Resources Delivered Straight To Your Inbox

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
We respect your privacy. Learn more here.

Related Blogs

AI Governance Maturity Models 101: Assessing Your Governance Frameworks
  • AI
  • July 5, 2024
Learn How To Asses The Maturity Of Your AI Governance Model
AI Governance Audits 101: Conducting Internal and External Assessments
  • AI
  • July 5, 2024
Learn How To Audit Your AI Governance Policies
AI Ethics Training 101: Educating Teams on Responsible AI Practices
  • AI
  • July 5, 2024
Learn How To Teach Your Teams About AI Ethics.
AI Interpretability 101: Making AI Models More Understandable to Humans
  • AI
  • July 4, 2024
Learn How To Understand AI Models
Threat Modelling, Risk Analysis and AI Governance For LLM Security
  • AI
  • July 3, 2024
Explore The Privacy, Governance and Security Challenges Posed By LLMs
AI Incident Response 101: Handling AI Failures and Unintended Consequences
  • AI
  • June 28, 2024
Discover Best Practices For AI Incident Response
Addressing Shadow AI Risks with Zendata AI Governance
  • AI
  • June 12, 2024
Learn How Zendata Helps To Address Shadow AI Risks
AI Risk Assessment 101: Identifying and Mitigating Risks in AI Systems
  • AI
  • June 6, 2024
Learn How To Identify And Assess AI Risks
From RAG to Agent Systems: The Transition to GenAI 2.0
  • AI
  • June 6, 2024
Learn More About GenAI 2.0 And What It Means For Businesses
More Blogs

Contact Us For More Information

If you’d like to understand more about Zendata’s solutions and how we can help you, please reach out to the team today.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.





Contact Us For More Information

If you’d like to understand more about Zendata’s solutions and how we can help you, please reach out to the team today.

AI Governance Policies 101: Drafting Effective Guidelines for AI Development and Use

June 3, 2024

TL:DR

Artificial intelligence (AI) is already changing how we do business and how we live. Its capabilities are quickly rendering traditional programming governance policies and standards obsolete, yet these programs are used to make decisions that significantly affect people’s lives.

AI governance policies are frameworks that facilitate the ethical and responsible use of AI technologies. These policies aim to eliminate bias and increase AI accountability and transparency in systems. Businesses also implement AI governance policies to comply with existing data privacy and protection regulations as well as new and emerging AI regulations.

Understanding AI Governance Policies

As Christian Lange stated over 100 years ago, “Technology is a useful servant but a dangerous master.” An AI governance policy helps keep AI technology firmly in the servant category. It’s a structured framework intended to promote the responsible development and use of AI technology. These policies address the ethical, legal, and society-wide ramifications of AI so businesses and governments can take advantage of the potential of AI without causing harm.

Definition and Scope

AI governance policies define standards and practices for developing and using AI to make sure they’re implemented in ways that are fair, transparent, and accountable. They’re applicable to every stage of AI development, from planning to deployment. Effective governance policies prevent potential harm such as privacy violations and biases in decision-making and promote beneficial and equitable outcomes.

Key Elements of AI Governance Policies

The field of AI governance is still in its infancy, with the EU leading the way in regulating AI technologies. The EU AI Act was passed in March of 2024 — though it will be gradually phased in over 24 months — and the White House issued a Blueprint for an AI Bill of Rights that will likely shape future US regulations. You can expect more international, federal, and state regulations to follow in the near future.

However, for now, businesses are largely on their own in developing governance policies. Your AI governance framework should be customized to your specific use cases, but all policies should include the following elements.

Ethical Guidelines

An AI governance policy should clearly outline the ethical principles you’ll follow in developing or using an AI system. This includes promoting fairness, equity, and respect for human rights. These policies can do this by requiring measures such as bias mitigation and inclusivity. Your governance policy should also include guidelines for considering the wider ethical implications of AI decisions. AI systems that have more power need more ethical governance.

Compliance Requirements

Although AI-specific regulations are currently limited, AI technology still needs to comply with existing laws and regulations. Governance policies should outline how you’ll adhere to data protection laws, industry standards, and international regulations, so your AI programs won’t infringe on individual rights or privacy.

Risk Management

Your governance framework should include practices for identifying, assessing, and mitigating risks associated with AI technologies. You need to systematically evaluate the potential for unintended consequences, security vulnerabilities, and the impact of AI decisions on individuals and communities. A strong risk management framework will help you anticipate and respond to challenges effectively.

Transparency Measures

AI concepts such as machine learning algorithms and neural networks are complicated and difficult for lay people to understand. Standards that call for transparency in AI systems, including clear documentation of AI models, decision-making processes, and data sources, can help build trust with consumers and society. Transparency measures should also extend to how businesses and governments use AI systems so people aren’t deceived.

Importance of AI Governance Policies

Depending on who you believe, AI will either save the world or destroy humanity. Even if you fall into the dwindling middle ground and don’t buy into either extreme, AI undoubtedly has the power to reshape our society for good or ill. AI governance policies aim to shift the balance towards the good side.

Ethical AI Development and Use

When you’re designing an AI application to offload a tedious and time-consuming task, the benefits seem obvious, and the potential negative repercussions less so. However, because machine learning programs often operate in a “black box” — that is, even their creators aren’t sure how they'll make a decision — they may be discriminating against people based on race, gender, or other protected classes. AI explainability can shed some light on this process, but it's not available in all systems.

Even if an AI technology isn’t discriminatory, its widespread use may lead to unforeseen consequences. Generative AI has already increased the productivity of many software teams, and there’s concern that it may replace wide swaths of knowledge workers, which could decimate the economy if left unchecked.

AI governance policies put guardrails on AI programs to prevent individual and community harm from AI.

Regulatory Compliance

An AI governance policy will help you comply with all applicable laws and regulations in your industry and use cases. Noncompliance carries the risk of significant financial and legal penalties. The AI regulatory landscape is rapidly changing, so an AI governance policy should be flexible enough to adapt to new laws.

Risk Management

Governance policies provide frameworks for assessing potential risks, such as biases, security vulnerabilities, and unintended consequences. By implementing robust risk management strategies, you can proactively address these challenges and implement more reliable and secure AI systems.

Building Trust

Clear guidelines on fairness, privacy, and data protection reassure users and customers that their rights are respected. AI transparency measures, such as explainable AI and thorough documentation, allow stakeholders to understand how AI programs make decisions. When you demonstrate a commitment to responsible use, you create a trustworthy environment with your customer base and the broader community.

Steps to Draft Effective AI Governance Policies

To create AI governance policies that reflect your ethical, legal, and operational concerns, you need to consider how you incorporate AI into your current business practices and how that role is likely to expand in the future. The following steps will help you lay the groundwork for effective AI governance.

Establish Clear Objectives

The first step in drafting your AI governance policies is to determine exactly what you want to achieve. Identify the specific AI applications it will cover along with data sources and other related systems. This starting point will give you a clear direction and guide the rest of your plan.

Engage Stakeholders

AI systems can affect people at all levels of your organisation. Include voices from all departments and disciplines, including developers, data scientists, executives, legal representatives, and users. Input from all impacted groups will help you create more holistic and comprehensive policies.  

Conduct a Risk Assessment

The ultimate goal of your governance policies is to protect people from risks associated with AI. To do this, you need to identify potential legal, financial, social, and operational risks. After you perform AI risk assessments, you can develop strategies to mitigate these risks.

Define Roles and Responsibilities

AI governance is an ongoing job that’s best managed by a team with wide-ranging representation and expertise, including data and security. Your framework should clearly define who will be on the team and what their responsibilities are.

Develop Ethical Guidelines

Your AI ethical guidelines should align with your corporate values. It should answer questions about how you’ll use AI in your organisation and how your core values will guide your AI adoption. You can draw on your existing ethical frameworks to identify best practices and gaps you should cover. Establish accountability measures such as oversight committees and regular audits.

Establish Compliance Mechanisms

Compliance mechanisms guarantee your AI systems adhere to relevant laws, regulations, and ethical guidelines and protect users’ rights. Start by identifying all regulations that apply to your industry and use case. Then set up comprehensive compliance policies that outline how you’ll meet all the specific regulatory requirements, including training programs and reporting systems.

Implement Monitoring and Auditing Processes

Your AI governance policies only have value if you follow them closely. Continuous monitoring helps you discover issues early so you can correct them. Determine what aspects of your AI systems need to be monitored, such as data inputs and decision-making processes. Set up real-time monitoring systems that can track the behavior of your AI systems and alert you to noncompliance.

In addition to regular monitoring, your governance policies should include measures for periodic audits. Develop detailed protocols that outline auditing procedures, including the frequency, scope, and methodologies of audits.

Create a Feedback Loop

A feedback loop will incorporate insights from stakeholders and your existing systems to improve your governance policies over time. Consider different feedback sources, such as users, developers, monitoring systems, and audit reports. Set up multiple channels for collecting feedback so they’re easily accessible. Develop processes for analyzing it as well — you may need to use data analysis tools to identify issues and areas for improvement. Incorporate these insights into your AI governance policies going forward.

Best Practices for Implementing AI Governance Policies

Once you’ve established AI governance policies, you need to follow a systematic approach to implementing them throughout your organisation.

Regular Training and Awareness Programs

You’ll have better implementation results for your AI governance policies if everyone understands their value and significance. Provide ongoing educational programs that explain ethical guidelines, compliance requirements, and best practices for responsible AI use.

Transparency and Communication

As you develop and implement your AI governance framework, maintain open lines of communication about policy details, updates, and compliance requirements. You can do this through clear documentation, holding regular informational meetings, and providing updates through multiple accessible channels.

Continuous Improvement

Your AI governance framework isn’t a static document. You should update it regularly based on new risks, technologies, regulations, and experience. Take the feedback you receive and advice from experts and use it to improve your policies and keep up with AI advancements.

Challenges in Drafting and Implementing AI Governance Policies

Rarely does any substantial change come off without a hitch, in any organisation. If you’re like most businesses, you can expect to face some challenges when drafting and implementing AI governance. Some of the most common challenges include:

  • Rapid AI advancements make it difficult to craft relevant, updated policies.
  • Stakeholder buy-in can be lacklustre due to competing priorities.
  • Overly strict governance policies can stifle innovation.

You can overcome these and other challenges by consulting legal and ethical experts to make sure your guidelines are comprehensive and forward-looking. Engage stakeholders at all phases of development and implementation to address their needs and concerns. They’ll be more likely to adopt policies they’ve had a voice in creating. There’s no slowing progress, but if you establish a process for regularly reviewing and updating your procedures, you can stay on top of industry changes and stay relevant.

Final Thoughts

Effective AI governance policies safeguard against risks such as biases, security vulnerabilities, and regulatory breaches and promote fairness and accountability. Investing in comprehensive, adaptable governance frameworks also builds trust in your brand and supports sustainable innovation and long-term growth.

Zendata AI Governance simplifies compliance, risk identification, and stakeholder engagement. Our detection, prevention, and correction controls provide insights and mitigate risks related to AI adoption in your organisation. Reach out today to find out how we can help you.

F‍AQ

How can businesses effectively manage the ethical risks associated with generative AI technologies in their AI governance policies?

Managing ethical risks in generative AI involves incorporating specific guidelines within AI governance policies that address the unique challenges posed by these technologies. This includes setting strict parameters for data usage to prevent misuse and ensuring that outputs are regularly audited for quality and ethical standards. Businesses should also engage in continuous risk assessments to adapt to the evolving nature of generative AI applications, ensuring they remain aligned with ethical principles and compliance requirements.

What specific transparency measures should organisations implement to clarify the decision-making processes of black-box AI models?

To enhance transparency in black-box AI models, organisations should implement detailed documentation practices that describe the data inputs, model architecture and algorithms used. Additionally, they should provide accessible explanations that can be understood by non-experts, such as simplified visual representations of how decisions are derived. Establishing regular transparency audits can also help ensure that these measures are consistently applied and effective.

In what ways can AI governance frameworks be tailored to mitigate biases specifically in AI recruitment tools?

AI governance frameworks tailored to mitigate biases in AI recruitment tools should include mandatory bias detection and mitigation procedures throughout the AI model development and deployment phases. This could involve training on diverse datasets, regular bias audits and the implementation of fairness algorithms. Additionally, these frameworks should enforce transparency in how recruitment decisions are influenced by AI, with clear documentation and the option for candidates to request explanations for automated decisions.

How can organisations ensure that their AI governance policies remain effective amidst rapid advancements in AI technology and changing regulations?

To ensure AI governance policies remain effective, organisations should adopt a dynamic approach that includes regular policy reviews and updates in response to technological advancements and regulatory changes. This involves setting up a dedicated oversight committee that monitors AI developments and compliance landscapes. Creating a culture of continuous learning and adaptation among employees and stakeholders through training and awareness programs can help maintain alignment with best practices in AI governance.

What role do data privacy laws play in shaping AI governance strategies, particularly in international operations?

Data privacy laws significantly shape AI governance strategies by setting legal standards for data handling and protection that organisations must comply with, especially in international operations. These laws influence how AI systems are designed, particularly in terms of data collection, storage, and processing practices. Organisations should develop compliance mechanisms within their AI governance frameworks that are strong enough to address the diverse requirements of different jurisdictions, ensuring global compliance and protecting user data across all operational areas.